Sunday, September 3, 2023

Free Weekly Instant Tournament - September 1 - Board 4

Board 4
Both sides vulnerable

♠ 5 2  ♥ A K 10 9  ♦ K 10  ♣ Q 10 9 7 5  

Three passes to me. I have only 14 Casino points (HCP plus spade length). Conventional wisdom is you need 15 Casino points to open in fourth seat, but I think that's wrong. Average is 13 1/3. I think anything above average is worth opening, so I open with one club.

LHO passes, partner responds one spade, and RHO passes. I bid one notrump, and partner bids three spades, invitational. I have a minimum in high cards and no spade fit. And partner's spades probably aren't very good, since he didn't open with a weak two bid. So I'm not worth an acceptance. It is close, however. As minimums go, this a good hand. Four controls, three tens, two nines. But I think I need a bit more than that to accept with a small doubleton spade.

I pass. RHO leads the diamond ace.


NORTH
Phillip
♠ 5 2
♥ A K 10 9
♦ K 10
♣ Q 10 9 7 5






SOUTH
Robot
♠ A K J 8 6 4
♥ J 5 3 2
♦ J 2
♣ 3


West North East South
Robot Phillip Robot Robot
Pass Pass
Pass 1 ♣ Pass 1 ♠
Pass 1 NT Pass 3 ♠
(All pass)

I'm not sure why partner didn't open two spades with that hand. Because of the four-card heart suit perhaps? If he felt that way, he should have opened one spade. You have to bid either two or one. Passing with that suit isn't an option. Besides, if you're just going to ignore the heart suit and treat the hand a spade one-suiter anyway, what does passing accomplish?

East plays the diamond six, presumably encouraging with the queen. Should I play the jack or deuce? The jack suggests I have shortness, since it would be an unlikely play from jack third. I want West to worry that I have three diamonds so that he might shift to a trump, so I play the deuce.

West continues with the nine of diamonds. East plays the three. Does West's failure to shift to a trump mark him with the trump queen? No. He might have a stiff trump, which would also be an unattractive shift. Or he might have six diamonds and be unconcerned about a diamond ruff, since his partner will be overruffing. Or he might decide that stopping the ruff is the wrong approach altogether. Forcing declarer to ruff a loser is sometimes a better strategy than leading trump.

Imagine, for example, I had two small diamonds left and king-queen sixth of spades. Two rounds of spades stops the ruff. But who says I need the ruff? I may be able to pitch the third diamond somewhere. As long as I have the diamond king to stop the suit, there is no hurry to dispose of my third diamond. Knocking out the diamond king, however, may give me a problem. I win, play a spade to the queen, and it holds. Now what? What if I can't take my pitch without drawing trump first? If I play another trump, the defense can cash a diamond. If I ruff the diamond, I can't lead up to the spade king.

This is only one scenario where exposing the third-round diamond loser is a better strategy than leading trump. I'm sure you can think of others. In short, there is a variety of reasons West might have for not shifting to a trump. So I see no reason to spurn the spade finesse.

Should I take a first-round finesse or cash the ace to guard against a stiff queen? If I play a spade to the ace, I must then return to dummy with a heart to take the spade finesse. If the finesse loses and West plays another heart, I have a problem. If I take the heart finesse, East might win and give his partner a heart ruff. 

That's not even the only problem with this line. I may be able to set up two club tricks, so I can avoid a heart finesse altogether. But I can't do that if I waste heart entries. Suppose West has honor-jack tight of clubs, for example. After I draw trump, I play a club. If he hops and plays a heart, I win and lead the queen of clubs. I know from the opening lead West doesn't have both high club honors, so if East doesn't cover, I can let it ride safely, pinning the jack

To keep my heart entries intact, I'm going to pay off to a stiff queen of spades offside. I play a low spade to the jack. West wins with the queen and continues with the spade ten to East's seven and my ace.

If I draw the last trump, I have to pitch dummy's fifth club. Is there any scenario where I need that fifth club? Perhaps. If the opponents make a mistake and play a second round of clubs for me, I get two ruffs. Say, for example, West hops with honor third of clubs and plays another one. I ruff out East's jack and still have two heart entries to ruff out his other honor and cash my tricks. Or suppose West ducks with honor-jack third and East wins and plays another club. Again, I can score two ruffs, setting up two club tricks, and still have a heart to get back to cash them.

Neither of those mistakes is likely. But they are possible, and I can't exploit them without five clubs in dummy. I don't see any pressing need to draw the last trump. So why not lead a club now to give the opponents a chance to make a mistake?

I play a club, West plays the deuce, and East takes dummy's nine with the jack. East returns the diamond queen. I ruff. West follows with the diamond five.

The club suit didn't pan out. I draw the last trump, pitching a club from dummy. West pitches the heart six; East follows with the spade nine. 

West pitched a heart? What heart holding might he be pitching from? Not queen third. His partner might have jack doubleton. Queen fourth? Maybe. Although with that holding he might have shifted to a heart at trick two, trying to give his partner a heart ruff.

I play the heart deuce--seven--ace--four. Now that I've seen the four, I know West's six was his lowest. The robots almost always pitch count cards if the suit hasn't been played yet. So it appears West made a careless discard from three small hearts.

I lead the club ten. East covers with the ace. I ruff, and West follows with the four. Now jack of hearts--eight--king--queen. Making four.


NORTH
Phillip
♠ 5 2
♥ A K 10 9
♦ K 10
♣ Q 10 9 7 5


WEST
Robot
♠ Q 10
♥ 8 7 6
♦ A 9 8 7 5
♣ K 4 2


EAST
Robot
♠ 9 7 3
♥ Q 4
♦ Q 6 4 3
♣ A J 8 6


SOUTH
Robot
♠ A K J 8 6 4
♥ J 5 3 2
♦ J 2
♣ 3

Plus 170 is worth only 54%. I thought dropping the offside heart queen might have been worth more. But most declarers dropped it. Some dropped the spade queen also and made five. Perhaps because of West's failure to shift to a trump at trick two? As I said at the time, West has other reasons for not shifting to a trump. I don't think the inference he has the queen is strong enough to make an anti-percentage play in the suit.

I did, however, make a mistake in not drawing the last trump. There was a slight advantage in not drawing it, and at the time I didn't think it could cost. But I was wrong.

To see why, suppose West did have honor-jack doubleton of clubs as I hoped. I play a club. He hops and leads a heart. I win and lead the club queen. If East covers, great! But what if he ducks?  If I pitch a heart, the club jack drops, but now I'm stuck in dummy in this position::


NORTH
Phillip
♠ --
♥ A K 10 9
♦ --
♣ 10 9 7






SOUTH
Robot
♠ K 8 6 4
♥ J 5 3
♦ --
♣ --

The spade nine is still out. If West has it, I'm in trouble.

In fact, suppose East is clever enough to duck the club queen even with honor-jack fourth remaining. Now if I pitch a heart, I could actually go down. The clubs don't set up, so I might lose a trump and the heart queen. That might teach me to draw trump.

Sunday, August 27, 2023

Free Weekly Instant Tournament - August 25 - Board 3

Board 3
Opponents vulnerable

♠ 8 3 2  ♥ K 4 3  ♦ A Q 6 4 3  ♣ A 9  

I open with one diamond, LHO bids two spades, weak, and partner makes a negative double.

This is the nightmare hand for rebidding after a negative double: no second suit, no stopper in the opponent's suit, and no rebiddable suit. My options are: pass, two notrump, three diamonds, and three hearts. 

If partner is short in diamonds, has at least two spades, and isn't minimum in high cards, pass might be the winner. But we have no reason to believe any of those three things is true. So passing is a shot in the dark. It would be a safer shot after a one-heart opening (with the red suits reversed, of course), since partner won't have support for our suit. But after one diamond--two spades, partner might double, for example, with a 1-4-5-3 pattern.

Two notrump might also work out. Partner might have a spade stopper, or spades might be blocked. But again, it's a shot in the dark. And holding three small spades makes the gamble that partner has a stopper a poor one. It would be a better gamble with a void.

Three hearts will be an excellent choice if we are lucky enough to catch partner with five hearts. But why should we be so lucky? Three hearts would be more attractive if we held a doubleton space, since at least we would be taking ruffs in the short hand if we have a four-three fit. 

Another problem with three hearts is that it's not 100% partner has four hearts. I know people say a negative double of one major promises at least four in the other. But what is responder supposed to do with, say,

♠ x x  ♥ A Q x  ♦ K x x  ♣ Q x x x x ?  

If pressed, most say they would "lie" and double anyway. Personally, I don't think double is a lie. It's a lie only because of the way many define the double.

If you define double as "a replacement for a one-heart response (excluding game forces with five or more hearts)," then, yes, it's a lie. But the fact most would double with the above hand suggests that's not an accurate definition. If it were, you wouldn't even consider doubling.

I prefer to define double as "take-out of spades (probably with four or five hearts)." That definition is more in keeping with the intent of the double and allows you to double with the above hand without feeling guilty. It also means that, as opener, you should be loathe to rebid in a three-card heart suit.

That brings us to three diamonds. If partner is savvy enough to avoid negative doubles with three cards in the opponent's suit, then there is a good chance partner has diamond support, so three diamonds will probably be best.  Even if partner is, say, 2-4-2-5, diamonds may be our best strain, since we are ruffing spades with the short hand (and probably being overruffed with a natural trump trick).

While any one of these four calls could work out, three diamonds will probably work out most often. Three diamonds will be a decent spot any time partner has three or more diamonds and will be a playable spot even if he has a doubleton.

I bid three diamonds. Everyone passes and LHO leads the king of spades.


NORTH
Robot
♠ J 9 6
♥ A J 9 6 2
♦ 8 5
♣ K 6 3






SOUTH
Phillip
♠ 8 3 2
♥ K 4 3
♦ A Q 6 4 3
♣ A 9


West North East South
Robot Robot Robot Phillip
1 ♦
2 ♠ Double Pass 3 ♦
(All pass)

To my mind, a negative double is a gross error with partner's hand. More on this in the post mortem.

East drops the queen of spades on this trick. West cashes the spade ace, and East discards the heart ten. East ruffs the next spade with the diamond ten and shifts to the club queen.

Assuming hearts are coming home and the diamond king is onside, all I need is four-two diamonds to make this. Although the pitch of the heart ten makes that looks unlikely. If the pitch was a singleton (and it would be a strange choice if it wasn't), I will need East to be 1-1-4-7.

I win the club in dummy and lead a diamond--seven--queen--nine. West shows out on the diamond ace, so I'm down one.


NORTH
Robot
♠ J 9 6
♥ A J 9 6 2
♦ 8 5
♣ K 6 3


WEST
Robot
♠ A K 10 7 5 4
♥ Q 8 7 5
♦ 9
♣ 8 2


EAST
Robot
♠ Q
♥ 10
♦ K J 10 7 2
♣ Q J 10 7 5 4


SOUTH
Phillip
♠ 8 3 2
♥ K 4 3
♦ A Q 6 4 3
♣ A 9


Minus 110 is worth 50%.

Passing works out best, since we collect 500 (although the one player who chose pass somehow allowed them to make it).

Next best is two notrump. With the blockage in spades, we can make three for plus 150.

After that comes three hearts. West can hold this to three, for plus 140, by leading his singleton. In practice at the tables that played three hearts, West started with king and ace of spades and gave his partner a ruff. Declarer should now make four, since he can pick up the trumps and squeeze East in the minors. Weirdly, all but one declarer went down after that start.

My choice of three diamonds comes in dead last. Some play fourth best opening leads. I play fourth best in the auction.

But I think this result is partner's fault for making a foolish negative double. The five-card heart suit and the tripleton spade are both flaws.

Sometimes you can't avoid a negative double with five cards in the unbid major. But if you can avoid it, you should, since a double makes it difficult to reach a five-three fit. With this hand, double is easy to avoid. You simply pass. If partner reopens with a double, you bid three hearts, reaching your five-three fit without requiring partner to make a speculative bid in a three-card suit. (This works better if you play lebensohl here, so that three hearts shows some values.)

More importantly, you should avoid a negative double with three cards in the opponent's suit, especially when the opponents are vulnerable. With three opposite three in the opponent's suit, whichever side buys the contract will probably go minus. Why should that be you? Your best choice is to pass. If partner is short in their suit, he will reopen. If he isn't, you will defend and likely go plus. In this case, you will collect 200 for a 100% board.

For a fuller discussion of this principle, see The Cooperative Pass.

Sunday, August 20, 2023

Free Weekly Instant Tournament - August 18 - Board 2

Board 2
Our sides vulnerable

♠ A 4  ♥ K 3  ♦ A K 9 7 4 3  ♣ Q J 7  

RHO opens with one heart. With 17 HCP and a good six-card suit, I'm a bit overstrength for a one-trump overcall. But one-notrump overcalls are frequently overstrength after one of a major, since if you double, the chance of the auction's staying at the one level is slim, and a two notrump rebid shows a better hand than this.

I bid one trump, LHO passes, and partner bids two clubs, Stayman. I bid two diamonds and partner rebids two notrump. I have a clear acceptance. I raise to three,] ending the auction. LHO leads the deuce of hearts.


NORTH
Robot
♠ K 10 9 7
♥ 9 6
♦ J 10 8
♣ A 10 9 2






SOUTH
Phillip
♠ A 4
♥ K 3
♦ A K 9 7 4 3
♣ Q J 7


West North East South
Robot Robot Robot Phillip
1 ♥ 1 NT
Pass 2 ♣ Pass 2 ♦
Pass 2 NT Pass 3 NT
(All pass)

If diamonds come home, I have ten tricks. If not, I'll need the club finesse. Is it possible for West to hold the club king? There are 15 HCP outstanding, so yes, it's possible.

I play low from dummy, and East takes the heart ace. That's unusual. Ducking the heart to preserve communication would be a more normal play. Winning the ace gives me the opportunity to duck the next heart when I have king third. I can then afford to lose the lead to West. That fact that East isn't worried about that possibility suggests he has the club king and isn't afraid his partner has the defense's only entry. 

In fact, holding the club king actually makes taking the ace attractive. If East ducks, I may be able to endplay him later. When I hold king doubleton, playing ace and a heart puts a stop to any possibility of my throwing him in with a heart.

East continues with the queen of hearts. West drops the four under my king. I cash the diamond ace and unblock the jack from dummy. West plays the five; East, the deuce.

I'm pretty confident East's defense marks him with the club king. So if someone shows out on the next diamond, I'm not taking the club finesse. I'll just give up a diamond and concede down one or down two, depending on how hearts break. I cash the diamond king. West follows with the six. I unblock the ten from dummy, and East drops the queen.

Good. I have ten tricks. Can I find an eleventh?. If East has the club king and both spade honors, he could be under some pressure. Suppose I come down to this ending:


NORTH
Robot
♠ K 10 9
♥ --
♦ --
♣ A 10






SOUTH
Phillip
♠ A 4
♥ --
♦ --
♣ Q J 7

If East has both spade honors, he must hold three spades and king doubleton of clubs, so he has had to discard all his hearts. I can now play ace and a club and make five. If East has only one spade honor, the squeeze doesn't work. He can hold me to four by coming down to two spades, two clubs, and a heart.

Maybe I can improve on that line. I don't need the club ace in the above position. The squeeze works just as well if the club ace has already been cashed. Perhaps I should lead the club queen to the ace now. This gives West a chance to cover if he has the king. I don't believe he does. But if it doesn't hurt to cater to the possibility, why not?

Or maybe it does hurt to cater to the possibility. East doesn't know my high cards. He won't be happy about discarding all his hearts. Maybe he'll play his partner for the club queen and stiff his king of clubs, letting me make six. Or, if he has just the spade jack, maybe he'll play his partner for the spade ace instead of the queen and stiff his jack.

I might improve the chances of East's going wrong by coming down to this position:


NORTH
Robot
♠ K 10 9 7
♥ --
♦ --
♣ A






SOUTH
Phillip
♠ A 4
♥ --
♦ --
♣ Q J 7

Stiffing the club ace makes it appear I have no interest in the club suit, so it might make East more likely to stiff his king. If East does have everything and comes down to three spades and two clubs, I can still make five by setting up a spade instead of a club.

All in all, playing for East to misread the position looks like a better chance than playing West for the club king. I cash the nine of diamonds. West plays the club three; East, the club five. If they are giving count, clubs are three-three, making East 3-5-2-3 or 2-6-2-3.

I cash three more diamonds, pitching clubs from dummy. On the first diamond, West pitches the six of spades; East, the jack of hearts. West appears to be giving count with four spades, so East is 3-5-2-3. If he has both spade honors, he has 15 HCP and probably would have opened with one notrump. So I suspect West has one of the spade honors, and the legitimate squeeze isn't going to work.

On the second diamond, West pitches the heart seven; East, the heart ten. If my reading is correct, East's last five cards are three spades, a heart, and king doubleton of clubs. On the final diamond, West pitches the eight of clubs. I pitch the ten of clubs from dummy, coming down to a stiff ace. East pitches the club six.

So this worked? East actually did stiff the club king? I play a club to the ace, dropping East's king, and claim the balance. Making six.


NORTH
Robot
♠ K 10 9 7
♥ 9 6
♦ J 10 8
♣ A 10 9 2


WEST
Robot
♠ J 6 3 2
♥ 7 5 4 2
♦ 6 5
♣ 8 4 3


EAST
Robot
♠ Q 8 5
♥ A Q J 10 8
♦ Q 2
♣ K 6 5


SOUTH
Phillip
♠ A 4
♥ K 3
♦ A K 9 7 4 3
♣ Q J 7

100%! The extra tricks were overkill. Even making a measly four notrump would have been worth 82%. A fair number of players overcalled one heart with two diamonds, either reaching five diamonds or missing game altogether. 

Whatever you think of offshape one-notrump openings, you can't afford to be too picky with one-notrump overcalls. Frequently they make the auction run smoothly and make it easy to reach games that would be difficult to reach otherwise. This applies in sandwich position as well in direct seat. 

Sunday, August 13, 2023

Free Weekly Instant Tournament - August 11 - Board 1

Board 1
Neither side vulnerable

♠ A Q J 9  ♥ A K J  ♦ --  ♣ K 9 8 7 6 2  

Two passes to me. I open with one club. LHO overcalls with one diamond, partner bids one spade, and RHO bids three clubs, showing a mixed raise of diamonds (four diamonds and seven to nine support points).

I don't need much for slam. King fifth of spades and queen doubleton of clubs may be enough. King fifth of spades and ace doubleton of clubs may be enough for a grand slam. The fifth spade is important, however. If partner has only four spades and I need to ruff a club to set up the suit, I won't have a trump left to take care of the third round of hearts. I don't have a slam drive. All I have is a strong invitation.

I could bid four diamonds, a splinter, showing a spade raise with diamond shortness, but I wouldn't feel comfortable respecting a signoff. Splinters should surrender captaincy. If you splinter and want to bid over partner's signoff, you shouldn't have splintered.

Checking the tooltips, I see the robots play that an insult cue-bid (three diamonds)  shows four-card spade support and a game force. I'm not sure that's the most common treatment. I should have thought it showed a game force with doubt about strain. But I'm happy for now that they play this way. I'll bid three diamonds, and if partner shows any sign of life, I'll drive to slam.

I bid three diamonds. LHO passes, and partner bids four notrump, Blackwood.

I'm not happy about this development. It would be better if I were in control of this auction, not partner. If I make my systemic bid of five notrump, showing two keycards and a void, we might miss a grand unless partner can be counted on to bid six diamonds any time we have all the keycards. Can he?

With something like

(A) ♠ K x x x x  ♥ x  ♦ x x x  ♣ A Q x x  

he should bid six diamonds, but I have no confidence he will. Actually, that's an unlikely hand anyway. It gives the opponents too many hearts. How about something like

(B) ♠ K x x x x  ♥ x x x  ♦ A x x  ♣ A x? 

With that hand, I don't think he should bid six diamonds. I think he needs a black-suit filler rather than the wasted diamond ace.

If partner does have the diamond ace, maybe my best move is to ignore my diamond void--to just show my keycards. If we have them all, partner is required to bid five notrump, then I can bid seven spades. No, that's not going to work. I have two keycards and the trump queen, so my Blackwood response is five spades. I can't risk partner's passing that.

Suppose I lie about my keycards and show only one? If partner bids six spades, then he must have three, and I can surprise him by raising to seven. If he signs off in five spades, I can bid six. In theory, that shows that my keycard response was based on four keycards rather than one. Might this induce partner to bid a grand off an ace? I don't see how. Since I'm looking at the spade queen and both round kings, partner can't have enough to go on to seven. This plan won't get us to a grand opposed (A), but at least it will get us there opposite (B), which is the likelier hand anyway.

I bid five diamonds. Partner bids five notrump, promising all the keycards. How is that possible? He presumably has six spades not to ask about the trump queen. But if he thinks we have all the keycards, he must have only one and is assuming I have four for my five-diamond bid. Can partner really be driving to slam with only one keycard and a hand he wasn't willing to open?

One thing for sure, I don't want him to bid a grand. So I must bid six spades, denying either of the kings I actually have. That should stop him from bidding seven. If anyone asks, I'll say I made a mistake when I bid five diamonds, which might be true anyway.

I bid six spades, and everyone passes. West leads the diamond jack.


NORTH
Phillip
♠ A Q J 9
♥ A K J
♦ --
♣ K 9 8 7 6 2






SOUTH
Robot
♠ K 7 6 5 4 3
♥ 7 5 2
♦ Q 3 2
♣ J


West North East South
Robot Phillip Robot Robot
Pass
Pass 1 ♣ 1 ♦ 1 ♠
3 ♣ 3 ♦ Pass 4 NT
Pass 5 ♦ Pass 5 NT
Pass 6 ♠ (All pass)

Partner's four-notrump bid seems a bit aggressive to me. Fortunately, I have him covered. I ruff in dummy with the trump nine. East plays the diamond seven.

I might as will get started on the club suit. I play a low club from dummy. East hops with the ace, and West follows with the five. East returns the three of clubs.

He must have ace-ten fourth and think his partner forgot to lead his singleton. I ruff small, and West follows with the queen.

Do I have a claim now? I can draw three rounds of trump and ruff a club to establish the suit. I still have a trump left to take care of dummy's heart. I claim.


NORTH
Phillip
♠ A Q J 9
♥ A K J
♦ --
♣ K 9 8 7 6 2


WEST
Robot
♠ 10 8
♥ Q 9 4 3
♦ K J 10 8 4
♣ Q 5


EAST
Robot
♠ 2
♥ 10 8 6
♦ A 9 7 6 5
♣ A 10 4 3


SOUTH
Robot
♠ K 7 6 5 4 3
♥ 7 5 2
♦ Q 3 2
♣ J

100%!

Since we didn't have a grand, my shenanigans weren't necessary. Simply responding accurately to Blackwood would have worked just fine. So why was no one else in slam?

Almost everyone bid four spades over three clubs and played it there. I don't think they appreciated the value of this hand. As I said earlier, this hand isn't quite worth a slam drive, but it's close. If I weren't allowed to invite--if I had to choose between bidding four or six--I would choose six.

Sunday, August 6, 2023

Free Weekly Instant Tournament - August 4 - Board 8

Board 8
Neither vulnerable

♠ A 10 6 5  ♥ A 8  ♦ A Q 6 5 4  ♣ A 4  

Three passes to me. I open with one diamond. Partner responds one spade, and I raise to four, ending the auction. West leads the diamond ten.


NORTH
Phillip
♠ A 10 6 5
♥ A 8
♦ A Q 6 5 4
♣ A 4






SOUTH
Robot
♠ Q J 7 3 2
♥ Q 6 5 2
♦ J 9 8 2
♣ --


West North East South
Robot Phillip Robot Robot
Pass Pass
Pass 1 ♦ Pass 1 ♠
Pass 4 ♠ (All pass)

The lead is probably a singleton. A lead from ten doubleton in dummy's suit would be unusual. So if I take a spade finesse and it loses, I will run into a ruff. Perhaps I can take advantage of the robots' belief that I am double-dummy.

If I lead the spade queen from my hand, will West cover if he has the king doubleton? If I have queen empty fifth, failing to cover will cost a trick, and the robots avoid plays that might lose and can't gain double-dummy. So yes, he will cover.

Will he cover with king third? If I have queen fifth, he can't take a spade trick whether he covers or not. If I have queen fourth, he always takes a spade trick whether he covers or not. Since it can't gain to cover, he might choose not to.

Wait. I'm wrong about that. If he has king-nine-eight, he does gain a trick by covering if East has the stiff jack. So he will cover with king-nine-eight but might choose not to with other three-card holdings.

How about king fourth? Again, he is entitled to one trick whether he covers or not, so he might not.

Let's assume that the lead is a singleton and that West will cover the spade queen with king doubleton or with king-nine-eight but not with other holdings. Under those assumptions, what is my best play if I lead the queen and West follows small? Overtaking with the ace (A) works if East has king doubleton (3 cases) or stiff king (1 case). Four cases in all. Letting the queen ride (B) works if East has a singleton eight or nine (2 cases) or a void (1 case). Three cases. (A) works more often.

Even if (B) worked more often, I would still have to consider (A). My analysis assumed West would always duck when covering can't gain, which might not be true. If he thinks his play doesn't matter, I'm not sure what he would do. Perhaps he would randomize. So I'm glad (A) is a clear winner and I don't have to worry about that.

I play the diamond ace. East plays the seven. I drop the jack, the card I'm known to hold. 

I play a club off dummy. East hops with the king. I ruff, and West follows with the eight. I lead the spade queen, intending to play the ace if West doesn't cover. He does cover. I take the ace, and East follows with the eight.

I have only a heart loser left. Can I avoid it? I can cash the club ace and draw trump. If I can then sneak a diamond past East, I can throw him in with the diamond king. If he has the heart king, he is endplayed. Is there any chance this will work?

I played the diamond jack at trick one. From East's point of view, his partner could have the nine. So he might well duck. Of course, he should know better. By time I play a diamond off dummy, he will know I began with five spades. That means I have at most five hearts and at least three diamonds. And I wouldn't play the jack at trick one with jack-empty third. Fortunately, the robots don't think that way. They make no assumptions about I would play. So East might think it's possible his partner led from ten-nine doubleton.

I cash the club ace. What should I pitch? If I pitch a diamond, East might worry I started with jack-nine third and hop when I lead a diamond off dummy. I want him to know I have at least two diamonds left, so I can't afford to pitch one. I pitch a heart instead.

I don't know whether I need to draw one round of trumps or two, but I know I want to end up in dummy, so I lead spade to my jack. Both follow. Now I lead a spade back to dummy. West plays the heart three; East, the club six.

I play a low diamond from dummy. East plays the seven. Wow! Did this actually work? I win and exit with a diamond. East wins and shifts to the heart jack--queen--king. Oh, well. It was worth a try. Making five.


NORTH
Phillip
♠ A 10 6 5
♥ A 8
♦ A Q 6 5 4
♣ A 4


WEST
Robot
♠ K 4
♥ K 9 7 4 3
♦ 10
♣ Q 8 7 5 3


EAST
Robot
♠ 9 8
♥ J 10
♦ K 7 3
♣ K J 10 9 6 2


SOUTH
Robot
♠ Q J 7 3 2
♥ Q 6 5 2
♦ J 9 8 2
♣ --

With jack-ten of hearts, East knew ducking the diamond was safe. Would he have ducked holding the heart king or the jack without the ten? We'll never know.

Plus 450 is worth 75%. Quite a few players won the opening lead and played ace and a spade, not bothering to give West a chance to cover the spade queen.

Not a single player other than me dropped the diamond jack at trick one. I thought at the time that this play was routine. But in retrospect, even though it turned out to give me a miniscule chance for a second overtrick, I think it was an error.

While the jack is "the card I'm known to hold" from East's perspective, it isn't from West's. Once I drop it, West knows the defense can't have two diamond tricks. So I must make a judgement about which opponent I prefer to keep in the dark. Since West has the critical play to make (choosing whether to cover the spade king or not), it's probably better to give West as little information as possible. It's hard to see how knowing where the diamond jack is will affect his decision. But I don't need to see how. Keeping the defender with the critical decision in the dark as much as possible is simply good practice.

Sunday, July 30, 2023

Free Weekly Instant Tournament - July 28 - Board 7

Board 7
Both sides vulnerable

♠ A K  ♥ A Q 8 4 3  ♦ J 9 8  ♣ Q 7 3  

I'm in first seat. With five hearts, a balanced hand, and 15 or 16 HCP, you pretty much have to open with one notrump. If you open with one heart, you have no rebid after a one spade response.

I bid one notrump, partner bids two hearts, a transfer to spades. I bid two spades, and partner bids four hearts, showing slam interest with six spades and a singleton or void in hearts.

I'm hardly worth a move past game. The queen of hearts and the fifth heart are probably wasted, and I have only a doubleton spade (although as doubletons go, it's not a bad one to have). I bid four spades and partner passes. West leads the diamond three.


NORTH
Robot
♠ Q J 10 9 6 2
♥ 9
♦ A Q 4
♣ A 10 2






SOUTH
Phillip
♠ A K
♥ A Q 8 4 3
♦ J 9 8
♣ Q 7 3


West North East South
Robot Robot Robot Phillip
1 NT
Pass 2 ♥ Pass 2 ♠
Pass 4 ♥ Pass 4 ♠
(All pass)

Unless I run into very bad luck, all I can lose is two clubs and a diamond, so I'm probably making this. Can I make an overtrick? If West has led from the diamond king, I don't have a diamond loser. I might also be able to establish a second club trick. Or I might be able to set up hearts to discard one or both clubs.

If I hope to set up a long heart trick, I will need an entry to my hand after drawing trump. The club queen might be an entry if East has the king. But in that case, a long heart trick is doing me no good, since I have nothing to pitch. The only way I can profit from long heart tricks is to enter my hand with the diamond jack. And the only way I can do that is to play the queen at trick one and hope it loses to the king. That would be an embarrassing play if West has led from the king. Now I'm taking only two diamond tricks when I'm entitled to three.

Is it worthwhile to take that risk? The robots don't like aggressive leads in general. And an aggressive lead into a one-notrump opener is particularly unattractive. So it's more likely than not that the diamond king is on my right. On the other hand, it's not entirely clear the hand entry will be useful. It will be useful if I can set up two heart tricks and pitch both of dummy's small clubs. But if I can pitch only one club and the club king is on my right, the pitch gains nothing.

The robots' leads sometimes surprise me, so I'm hesitant to make a speculative play on the assumption I know what West would lead from. I might do so if I were sure I would gain a trick if I were right. But since it's not clear I will, it doesn't seem worth the risk. I play low from dummy.

East wins with the king and shifts to the five of hearts. His failure to return a diamond suggests the opening lead was from length. If it was from three-deuce doubleton, East, with five diamonds, might have returned in diamond, hoping his partner had a singleton.

Should I finesse? Essentially, I must decide whether to play East for the heart  king by finessing or to play him for the club king by hopping and playing a club toward my queen later. He is no more likely to have one king than the other., so it might seem like a tossup. But if I finesse and I'm wrong, I'm out of options. I'm making only four. If I play him for the club king and I'm wrong, I still have chances for an overtrick. The club jack might drop, or I might be able to force a club play from the defense in the end position.

And there is another possibility. If West has king third of hearts, I can ruff it out. Heart ace, ruff, spade to my hand ruff, setting up my queen. Now I play another spade to my hand and lead the heart queen. If West is out of trumps, I get a pitch. If he ruffs, I overruff and am back to trying to play clubs for one loser. So while my play a tossup as far as the location of the kings is concerned, refusing the finesse gives me extra chances that taking the finesse doesn't.

I hop with the heart ace. West follows with the deuce.

Now to try to ruff out king third of hearts. I play the heart three--six--spade nine. East drops the heart king. So East had king doubleton.

The heart king dropping on my right isn't what I was hoping for. I could cash two trumps, then cash the heart queen, pitching a club, and hope East is out of trumps. But for all I know I'm pitching a winner. So that can't be the right line.

Maybe I can utilize the heart queen another way. I can draw trump, cash the diamonds, and play a club to the queen. If it loses to the king and West is out of diamonds, he has to give me the heart queen or lead a club for me, allowing me to finesse against the jack.

I cash the ace and king of spades. Both opponents follow. I cross to dummy with a diamond. West plays the deuce; East, the ten. The deuce? So West had five diamonds? With 2-5-5-1, surely he would have led his stiff club. He must be 3-5-5-0. But then East, with seven clubs, should have been able to figure that out and give him a club ruff. I must be wrong about West's having diamond length. He must have begun with a doubleton. I don't know why East didn't continue diamonds at trick two. How did he know the lead wasn't a singleton?

I cash the spade queen. East follows; West pitches the club six.

On the third diamond, West pitches the heart seven. So he was 2-5-2-4. We've reached this position:


NORTH
Robot
♠ J 10
♥ --
♦ Q
♣ A 10 2


WEST
Robot
♠ --
♥ J 10 x
♦ --
♣ ? ? ?


EAST
Robot
♠ --
♥ --
♦ x x x
♣ ? ? ?


SOUTH
Phillip
♠ --
♥ Q 8
♦ J
♣ Q 7 3

I have a 75% chance of a second club trick. I play the deuce of clubs--eight--queen--king. West continues with the five of clubs--ten--jack. Making four.


NORTH
Robot
♠ Q J 10 9 6 2
♥ 9
♦ A Q 4
♣ A 10 2


WEST
Robot
♠ 5 3
♥ J 10 7 6 2
♦ 3 2
♣ K 9 6 5


EAST
Robot
♠ 8 7 4
♥ K 5
♦ K 10 7 6 5
♣ J 8 4


SOUTH
Phillip
♠ A K
♥ A Q 8 4 3
♦ J 9 8
♣ Q 7 3

Plus 620 is worth 29%. Why is it so bad? A fair number of declarers made five. But not by superior play. In every case, the player opened with one heart and played four spades from the other side, getting a club lead.

What did they rebid after one heart--one spade? Some tried one notrump. Some tried two hearts. Some tried two clubs. It hardly seems fair that the players who gave themselves an impossible rebid problem by opening one heart were rewarded while those who had the foresight to open one notrump were punished.

On the other hand, I can't be too angry with the bridge gods, since I did have two opportunities to make five. One way, finessing the heart queen, is clearly wrong. But I'm not so sure about my play at trick one. Perhaps I was too cowardly. If I have the courage to play the diamond queen--assuming East doesn't duck it--I can make five easily. Now when the heart king ruffs out, I can draw trump and return to my hand with the diamond jack to cash the heart queen.

Incidentally, crossing to dummy with a diamond to draw the last trump was an error. Because of the inference I drew at trick two, I had the fixation that West had diamond length. But that was a deduction, not a fact. I knew for a fact ruffing a heart to dummy high was safe. I don't remember what I was thinking when I chose to play a diamond instead. I'm sure I had some reason, but I can't imagine it was a good one.

Sunday, July 23, 2023

Free Weekly Instant Tournament - July 21 - Board 6

Board 6
Opponents vulnerable

♠ A 6 4  ♥ 10  ♦ A K 7 4  ♣ K J 9 8 2  

RHO opens with one spade.

I could overcall with two clubs, but I prefer either a longer or a better suit for a two-level overcall. So I'm inclined to pass. 

Many players would not even consider passing with 15 HCP. But there is no necessity to bid in a competitive auction simply because you have a lot of high-card points. Those high cards will take tricks on defense as well as on offense.

The most important consideration is whether you have a good fit. We might have one, but why should it be clubs? If I'm going to enter the auction, I want to bring other suits into the picture. The way to do that with a three-suited hand is to make a take-out double. If the opponents deprive you of that chance by thoughtlessly bidding some suit other than your shortness, you simply wait for them to bid your shortness, then double. So the best way to handle this hand is to pass, hoping for the continuation

West North East South
1 ♠
Pass 1 NT Pass 2 ♥
Double

Note this double is a three-suited takeout, not a two-suited takeout. With a minor two-suiter worth entry at this level, you would have overcalled or bid two notrump on the first round. So spades are in the picture, and spade bids by partner are natural.

While you are more likely to want to play spades if the opponents are playing four-card majors, it's not impossible that you belong in spades even if one spade promises five. I have played spades twice after similar sequences against five-card-majorites. On one occasion, one spade was a psyche, which we were able to brush aside. On the other, the four-three spade fit was our best spot despite the five-one break. (As Lowenthal liked to say, a four-three fit that is known to break five-one is often the best spot on a misfit. It's the only trump suit where the opponents can't crossruff.)

Another possibility with this hand is to overcall with one notrump. But the singleton heart is a serious flaw--more so than a singleton minor would be. A belated double of hearts describes my hand perfectly, so why should I distort my hand?

I pass, LHO bids one notrump, partner passes, and RHO spoils my plan by bidding two spades.

Since I didn't get a chance to double two hearts, should I be kicking myself for not acting on the first round? Hardly. In fact, this possibility is one of the benefits of passing. Holding a singleton in a suit nobody wants to bid suggests a misfit. Somebody out there has hearts. Most likely hearts is LHO's best suit and partner has hearts stacked behind him, so our defensive prospects look good. I'm happy I chose to stay out of the auction.

I pass again. LHO raises to three spades--pass--pass back to me. Better yet. I get to defend three spades instead of two. This bid should show a doubleton spade. With a prepared three-card limit raise, one generally raises to four once you discover partner has a six-card suit. I'm quite pleased with how this auction has turned out. We have a fair chance to go plus here. I pass.

Should I lead my singleton or the diamond king? Several top players have told me that you should always lead from an ace-king. Even if another lead is better, they say, partner will often misdefend, thinking you can't have that ace-king. On the other hand, Garozzo once told me you should always lead your singleton. What are you supposed to do when you have two conflicting "always" rules? I guess you have no choice but to think.

In this case, the singleton heart strikes me as a better lead. While it is unlikely partner has an entry to give me a ruff, a heart lead may cause communication problems for declarer. He will be unable to lead a second one without drawing trump. And if we need to cash diamond tricks, I have plenty of time. I have clubs wired, and I have the trump ace. So declarer isn't getting any early diamond pitches.

I lead the heart ten and see the following dummy:


NORTH
Robot
♠ 8 3
♥ A K J 5
♦ J 6 3 2
♣ 7 4 3


WEST
Phillip
♠ A 6 4
♥ 10
♦ A K 7 4
♣ K J 9 8 2






West North East South
Phillip Robot Robot Robot
1 ♠
Pass 1 NT Pass 2 ♠
Pass 3 ♠ (All pass)

Declarer rises with the heart ace, partner plays the four, and declarer follows with the nine.

If partner wants to encourage, he should play the highest spot he can afford. Declarer has at most three hearts. So even if declarer has 987, partner must have the six. The four can't be partner's highest card, so it must be his lowest, marking declarer with 932. Is that possible? Would declarer squander the nine with 932? Either declarer has made a strange play or partner has played an impossible card.

What should a low card mean here? To my mind, it suggests a s shift to the suit I'm most apt to want to shift to, which, looking at this dummy, is clubs. If partner can't stand a club shift, he should encourage even without the heart queen. But the robots don't know how to signal, so I can draw no inference from partner's card. Instead I have to rely on probabilities and inferences from the play. It's a lot of work defending with a robot, but it's good practice at inference and calculation.

With that in mind, let's practice. What is declarer's likeliest shape? He should bid a four-card heart suit in preference to rebidding spades, so hearts are probably five-three. Six-two is possible, but not if partner's four is an honest card. Even if it isn't, a five-three is a priori more likely.

There are five cards missing in each minor, so each minor is apt to be three-two. That makes 6-3-2-2 declarer's single likeliest shape, although 6-3-1-3 or 6-3-3-1 are tied for a close second.

What about high cards? There are 16 HCP missing. Declarer probably has 11 or 12, leaving partner with 4 or 5. The heart queen rates to be two of them, simply because that's partner's longest suit. He probably has one of the two minor-suit queens as well.

Of course this is nothing more than a percentage guess, subject to revision as the play progresses. But I have to start somewhere. I'll consider the play against that construction first, then see what assumptions I can relax.

If that is in fact the layout, what tricks do we have? We can take a spade, two diamonds, and a heart. We might have a club trick as well for the setting trick, but it might be hard to take. If declarer has the diamond queen, he can set up a pitch on dummy's jack.

Maybe I can switch to a club on winning the first diamond, hoping partner has the club queen. Wait. That's no good. Even if that works, declarer can simply pitch a heart instead of a club. We take a club trick but lose the heart trick. It seems if declarer is 6-3-2-2, I have to hope partner has the diamond queen so dummy's jack is useless.

If so, do we take five tricks on a passive defense? Maybe not. Perhaps declarer can set up a heart for a club discard. Come to think of it, surely he can. He wouldn't have played the heart nine at trick one without the eight. So he can simply lead the eight and ride it to set up a discard for his club. To take a club trick, we need to play clubs, preferably from partner's side, before declarer sets up the heart trick. Since I need partner to have the diamond queen anyway, perhaps, when I win the spade ace, I should underlead to it, so he can switch to clubs.

That's a scary defense, and I have no particular reason to believe my provisional construction is correct. Maybe there's a safer way to try for five tricks.

Suppose declarer is 6-3-3-1, which is only slightly less likely than 6-3-2-2. Now I can win the first spade and play ace-king and a third diamond. Partner ruffs and gives me a heart ruff. This has the advantage that it works on any distribution of high cards where partner has a doubleton diamond. The previous line requires both declarer to be 6-3-2-2 and partner to have both red queens.

Does it hurt to try for a diamond ruff if declarer has the doubleton? If declarer has queen doubleton, it doesn't. There was no way for me to stop him from taking a pitch on the diamond jack. If he has two small, however, three rounds of diamonds will ruff out partner's queen third, giving declarer a diamond trick he could not score himself. But maybe that won't matter. Declarer was getting a club pitch on the fourth heart anyway. Unless partner has the club ace, ruffing out partner's queen of diamonds does cost anything. This certainly looks like a better line than underleading my ace-king of diamonds.

What about the possibility that partner has the club ace? If he does, I need to shift to a club when I win the spade ace. We get a spade, two minor suit aces, a heart ruff, and whichever minor-suit king cashes, possibly even both. If a partner I trusted played a low heart at trick one, I would consider that line. But that's too specific a holding to play for when all I'm doing is guessing. I'm better off playing for a specific shape and any lie of the high cards than I am playing partner for a specific card I have no reason to believe he has.

At trick two, declarer plays the eight of spades--five--king. He wouldn't play the king without the queen, so if I were intending a passive defense, I would simply duck. I might learn something from seeing what declarer does next. Since I have decided to try for a diamond ruff, I can't afford to duck. I have plans for partner's second trump. I take the ace and switch to the diamond king--deuce--five--ten.

Partner's five is the lowest outstanding diamond. What should his card mean here? Should high show a doubleton, looking for a ruff? Or should it show the queen, looking for an underlead? I believe it should show the queen. If a small diamond shows any three-card holding, partner has no idea whether to risk an underlead or not. Underleading is only chance, but if it's wrong it's probably costly. On the other hand, if you play that low denies the queen, then after a low card partner knows his only chance is to give you ruff. And that might not cost if it's wrong.

Of course, with this partner, I'm on my own. His card is no help.

Do I have any clues? With queen-ten doubleton of diamonds, declarer might have falsecarded with the queen, hoping I think it's a singleton. Does the fact that declarer didn't falsecard suggest partner has the queen and I should switch back to plan A? In a sense, it's a restricted choice situation. Declarer might have played the queen if he had it; partner would not have. So partner is more likely to have the queen. Well, not exactly. That would be true if they were equally likely to hold the queen a priori. But they aren't. So all I can really say is that the chance partner holds the diamond queen has gone up.

How risky is an underlead? If partner started with queen doubleton, either underleading or giving him a ruff will work. If he started with a small doubleton, underleading is a mistake. What if he started with three small and my underlead lets declarer score his now stiff queen? Perhaps that doesn't matter. He gets one diamond trick either way. If I underlead, he scores the queen but no longer has the jack for a club discard. So we get a club trick instead of my diamond king. No, I'm wrong. He can float the eight of hearts to get a club discard. If he has the stiff queen left, we can take the diamond ace and a heart if I cash. We get only the heart if I underlead. 

Playing partner for the diamond queen on the basis of declarer's failure to falsecard seems like pretty shaky reasoning. The fact that I'm even thinking about it show why the falsecard is probably wrong. Why falsecard with a card you're hoping the defender plays his partner for? I'm going to stick to my plan.

I cash the diamond ace--three--eight--queen. I'm happy to see that card. Now the four of diamonds. Declarer plays low from dummy, partner plays the nine, and declarer ruffs with the deuce.

Declarer cashes the spade queen. Partner follows with the jack. Declarer draws my trump, leads a heart to dummy, pitches a heart on the diamond jack, and takes a losing club finesse. Making three.


NORTH
Robot
♠ 8 3
♥ A K J 5
♦ J 6 3 2
♣ 7 4 3


WEST
Phillip
♠ A 6 4
♥ 10
♦ A K 7 4
♣ K J 9 8 2


EAST
Robot
♠ J 5
♥ Q 8 6 4 2
♦ 9 8 5
♣ 10 6 5


SOUTH
Robot
♠ K Q 10 9 7 2
♥ 9 7 3
♦ Q 10
♣ A Q

Minus 140 is worth 71%.

As I suspected, partner played a pusillanimous four of hearts at trick one. Please don't do that, partner. The deuce or the eight. No other card is legal.

Also, I was wrong that declarer had the heart eight. I'm not sure why he played the nine at trick one. Surely that could be a useful card.

No one tried a one-notrump overcall, but a few players did bid two clubs. This worked out poorly for a strange reason. North doubled and South judged to bid two notrump rather than two spades, scoring 150. Steering the opponents into spades instead of notrump was not the reason I rejected the two-club overcall, but I'll take it.

Declarer could have made four in the end position to beat the plus 150s. He can rise with the diamond jack, then run trumps coming down to:


NORTH
Robot
♠ --
♥ K
♦ 6
♣ 7


WEST
Phillip
♠ --
♥ --
♦ 7
♣ K J


EAST
Robot
♠ --
♥ Q
♦ --
♣ 10 6


SOUTH
Robot
♠ --
♥ 7
♦ --
♣ A Q

Now a heart to the king squeezes me in the minors. Of course, he had no reason to believe I had the club king--or any reason to believe the jack of diamonds would live. If he plays the diamond jack and partner ruffs it, he loses his discard. So I hardly blame him for taking the line he took.